It’s Tuesday afternoon, February 3, 2026, and the Lok Sabha has basically been a textbook study in parliamentary law for the last 24 hours. Rahul Gandhi tried to drop a “truth bomb” regarding the 2020 China border standoff, but he ran straight into a wall of procedural red tape.
The thing is, the drama wasn’t just about what was said—it was about Rule 349 and an “unpublished” book that the government is treating like a state secret. Or nothing.
Also Read | Imran Khan and Bushra Bibi Sentenced to 17 Years in Jail
The “Four Stars” Showdown: Field Notes
It’s an ongoing situation where the Leader of the Opposition (LoP) is using a magazine article to bypass a book delay. Here’s the ground reality:
-
The Book in Limbo: General MM Naravane’s memoir, Four Stars of Destiny, was supposed to be out in 2024. As of February 2026, it’s still “under review” by the Ministry of Defence. Let’s be real—the government has been sitting on it for over two years.
-
The Caravan Leak: On February 1, The Caravan magazine published an explosive cover story quoting excerpts from the book. Rahul Gandhi tried to read these lines in Parliament, specifically about “Chinese tanks in Doklam” and a moment where the General was “handed a hot potato” by the political leadership. Those too.
Also Read | Imran Khan and Bushra Bibi Sentenced to 17 Years in Jail
-
The “Trap” of Rule 349: Speaker Om Birla invoked Rule 349(i), which says an MP can’t read a book or newspaper unless it’s directly connected to the “business of the House.” The Speaker’s logic? An unpublished memoir isn’t official business. And then the treasury benches started shouting “Fake News Factory” followed.
-
Rule 353 (The Allegation Rule): This was the second hammer. It says if you’re going to make a “defamatory or incriminatory” allegation, you have to give prior notice to the Speaker and the Minister. Rahul hadn’t, so the mic was cut. Or nothing.
Also Read | Imran Khan and Bushra Bibi Sentenced to 17 Years in Jail
The Procedural Playbook
| Rule Cited | The Official Wording | The Real-World Application |
| Rule 349(i) | “Member shall not read any book… except in connection with business.” | Used to stop Gandhi from reading the Caravan article. |
| Rule 352 | Bars offensive language or disrespectful remarks. | Treasury benches claimed quoting the Gen “demoralized forces.” |
| Rule 353 | Requires prior notice for “incriminatory” allegations. | The “Safety Valve” used to stop the speech mid-sentence. |
| Speaker’s Power | The Speaker can demand “Authentication.” | Rahul said it’s 100% authentic; the Govt said it’s “concocted.” |
And Here’s the Kicker…
The government told Rahul he could quote from published books like Himalayan Blunder (about the 1962 war). The thing is, they only want him to talk about the wars the Congress lost. Rahul’s counter-move? He took to the cameras outside and said, “If they aren’t scared, why won’t they let me read three lines from their own former Army Chief?” Those too.
One side comment—experts like PDT Achary say Rule 349 shouldn’t actually stop an MP from quoting a news magazine if it’s relevant to the debate. It’s a bit messy. Authentic, but a clear sign that the 2020 border clash is still the most sensitive topic in Delhi. It’s an ongoing situation. Or nothing.
Also Read | Imran Khan and Bushra Bibi Sentenced to 17 Years in Jail
End…
