Public discourse in West Bengal this week is dominated by a rare confrontation between the highest constitutional office of the land and the state administration. As per the latest correspondence from readers on Monday, March 9, 2026, there is a palpable sense of unease regarding the “public duel” over protocol, which many believe undermines the sanctity of national institutions.
While political friction is common in the state, the involvement of the Rashtrapati Bhavan has added a layer of gravity that many citizens find troubling.
Also Read | Imran Khan and Bushra Bibi Sentenced to 17 Years in Jail
The Murmu-Banerjee Duel: Institutional Dignity at Risk
Multiple readers from Howrah and Hooghly pointed out that while protocol is essential, the decision to escalate the matter through public remarks and protocol inquiries may further polarize the political landscape.
The Criticism: Readers suggest that the President’s public comments regarding attendance and venue arrangements invited a political response that could have been avoided via “quiet consultation.”
The Centre’s Role: Some citizens perceive the Union government’s swift intervention as potentially partisan, urging for greater restraint to protect institutional dignity.
The Santali Welfare Debate
The welfare of the Santhali community in North Bengal remains a core issue, though the “politicization” of the discussion is drawing fire.
Authentic Concerns: Readers from Nadia acknowledge the President’s long-standing association with tribal communities but warn that airing these concerns publicly during a politically charged period risks turning governance issues into a confrontation.
The “Protocol” Distraction: Citizens in Calcutta expressed confusion over how administrative questions regarding a tribal conference transformed into a national political dispute.
Also Read | Imran Khan and Bushra Bibi Sentenced to 17 Years in Jail
Culinary Narrowing: The Rise of Biryani Dominance
In a shift from politics to the plate, Roshmi Sengupta from Calcutta highlights a cultural loss in the city’s famed food scene.
The Biryani Trend: The dominance of biryani stalls is reportedly replacing “delicate preparations” like luchi and kochuri.
The Delivery Factor: The trend is partly driven by the fact that biryani “travels well” in delivery bags, whereas Bengali dishes with thin gravies or those requiring fresh frying are less compatible with the modern app-based delivery ecosystem.
H.K. Dua: Reflections on Professional Credibility
The passing of veteran journalist Hari Krishan Dua has invited reflection on a bygone era of journalism.
Legacy of Integrity: Readers noted that Dua managed to lead prominent newspapers and serve as a media adviser to Prime Ministers without losing his reputation for professional distance and credibility.
Reality Check
Disputes between a President and a CM are exceptionally rare in Indian history. Still, the underlying tension in Bengal often pulls neutral offices into the political fray. Therefore, while the protocol row is the headline, the real victims are administrative efficiency and the “quiet dialogue” traditionally used to resolve state-centre friction. In fact, the shift in Calcutta’s food scene is a classic example of market forces overriding cultural diversity—a trend seen in many global metros.
The Loopholes
The Centre has sought an explanation regarding protocol. In fact, this is a “Blue Book Loophole”—while the rules for presidential security and protocol are strict, they are often interpreted differently by state governments depending on the “political temperature.” Therefore, “procedural lapses” can easily be weaponized as political tools. Still, the “Biryani Loophole” remains; while biryani is the high-margin “sales guarantee” for vendors, the loss of pice hotels represents a decline in affordable nutrition for the working class.
Also Read | Imran Khan and Bushra Bibi Sentenced to 17 Years in Jail
What This Means for You
If you are following the Bengal political situation, expect the Centre-State divide to widen. First, realize that the protocol inquiry will likely lead to a new set of “compliance directives” for the state. Then, if you are a resident of Calcutta, understand that your local culinary heritage is under threat from commercial convenience; you should actively support smaller stalls selling traditional snacks to keep that diversity alive.
Finally, understand that institutional dignity is a shared responsibility. You should look for “measured conduct” from all constitutional offices rather than celebrating “public duels.” Before the next high-profile visit, check for official press releases from Rashtrapati Bhavan, which are typically less controversial than off-the-cuff public remarks.
What’s Next
The West Bengal government’s formal response to the protocol inquiry is expected within the week. Then, look for the Santali community’s leaders to potentially issue their own statement to steer the conversation back to tribal welfare. Finally, expect local heritage groups in Calcutta to launch “Save our Street Food” campaigns as the biryani dominance continues to grow.
Also Read | Imran Khan and Bushra Bibi Sentenced to 17 Years in Jail
End…
