In a move of unprecedented judicial assertiveness, the Supreme Court of India has clamped down on the NCERT (National Council of Educational Research and Training). On Thursday, February 26, 2026, a bench led by Chief Justice Surya Kant ordered the immediate withdrawal and seizure of a new Class 8 Social Science textbook, expressing “grave concern” over content that discussed corruption within the Indian judiciary.
The Chief Justice’s remarks were sharp, suggesting that the inclusion of such material was not an “inadvertent error” but a “gunshot” fired at the institution’s dignity.
Also Read | Imran Khan and Bushra Bibi Sentenced to 17 Years in Jail
The “Bleeding” Institution: Why the Court Intervened
The bench took suo motu cognisance of the matter after copies of the book entered the market.
-
Institutional Defamation: The Court argued that the text was designed to “defame the institution” in the minds of young students.
-
Inadequate Apology: While the NCERT issued a press release expressing “regret” for the error of judgment, the Court found the statement fell short of the formal apology required for such a high-level lapse.
The Controversial Content: Class 8 Curriculum
The revised chapter, ‘Role of the Judiciary in Our Society,’ was intended to explain the hierarchy of courts but expanded into systemic challenges.
-
Corruption Mentions: The text listed “corruption at various levels” as a challenge to justice.
-
Delayed Justice: The Solicitor General also took offense on behalf of the court regarding the phrase “justice delayed is justice denied,” arguing that the state cannot teach children that justice is effectively being denied in the country.
-
Perspective: Legal experts quoted in the row suggested that Class 8 students should be familiarized with the functions of governance rather than being introduced to complex institutional critiques without “critical analysis.”
Also Read | Imran Khan and Bushra Bibi Sentenced to 17 Years in Jail
Accountability: “Heads Must Roll”
Solicitor General Tushar Mehta assured the bench that the individuals responsible for the drafting—who referred to the judiciary in a negative light—would never again work with the UGC or any federal ministry. However, the Chief Justice remained firm, stating, “We would like to have a deeper probe… heads must roll! We won’t close the case.”
Reality Check
The debate centers on the balance between “transparency” and “institutional prestige.” Still, NCERT’s role is to provide a factual, balanced view of the Indian state. Therefore, while the judiciary’s internal accountability is a matter of public record, the Court views the introduction of these topics to 13-year-olds as a premature and biased education. In fact, the speed of the ban—extending even to international copies—shows that the 2026 judiciary is significantly more sensitive to its “public image” in the digital age.
The Loopholes
The NCERT claimed only 32 books entered the market. In fact, the Chief Justice noted that he was able to procure a copy from “sources” easily. Therefore, the “Withdrawal Loophole”—where digital versions and early print runs continue to circulate—is what led the Court to issue a blanket ban on sharing even parts of the book online. Still, the “Inadvertent Error” loophole used by the NCERT was flatly rejected by the bench, which characterized the move as a “calculated conspiracy.”
Also Read | Imran Khan and Bushra Bibi Sentenced to 17 Years in Jail
What This Means for You
If you are a parent of a Class 8 student or a school administrator, do not use the 2026 edition of the Social Science textbook. First, realize that possession or distribution of the banned content could technically be viewed as contempt of court under the new “seizure” order. Then, if your child has already started reading the chapter on the Judiciary, explain that the curriculum is undergoing a mandatory revision to include “inspirational” material as suggested by government sources.
Finally, understand that NCERT textbooks for other classes are also under scrutiny for “appropriate” content. You should wait for an official notification from your school board before purchasing any new 2026-27 session books. Before the next academic term, verify the “Edition Date” on the first page to ensure it is the revised, Court-approved version.
What’s Next
The Supreme Court has issued formal notices to the Federal Center and the NCERT Chairman, Professor Dinesh Prasad Saklani. Then, a high-level probe will be initiated to identify the specific authors of the “Judiciary” chapter. Finally, look for a completely revised Class 8 textbook to be released by late March 2026, focusing on the “positive roles and shaping of Indian democracy” by the courts.
Also Read | Imran Khan and Bushra Bibi Sentenced to 17 Years in Jail
End…
